Donate

Radical Return: Perfect Exhibition for the End of the World

svet14/11/26 21:0121


1 Around materiality

The artistic development is aligned with research on materiality. Get to know clay, charcoal, graphite, stone. An alliance of human, instrument, and material.


There is an evidential gap between the artists of these days. Some artists are digital and some artists stick to material, and one can ask themself what is the difference between these two that is shaping not only what they create, but what they are thinking.

I would stress as the main difference the approach to materiality. A digital artist, who is using digital tools, is creating a work in no-space, as it needs nothing to be stored and contained. The work in process is equal to the tool, the program, the software. It eats into the memory card, but the card is the same; it can be reused, and the project itself leaves almost no traces in this world once it is deleted. The trace is evident when it was shared and shown on the Internet, but before, it barely existed. The material artwork exists even before the creation. It exists as the material that is made as a potentiality of an artwork.

This is why we feel so excited every time we step into the art supply shop. It is huge; there is so much paper, colour, and possibilities of art that have already started to happen. The canvas is not only the base, but half of the materiality of the artwork. The crayons, the coal, the ink were shaped, poured, stored; for the artist’s hand touch, the creation has already started there, and it can not end without some continuity; these paints and canvases should go somewhere even if they are never opened or used.

The painter’s life is closely tied to the materiality of these supplies. The artist is not a floating abstract creator; they create not from the imagination, but from the potentiality that is the meeting of the material with their ideas. The paper is crumpled, soaked; it gets yellowish; it turns and gets thinner; it loses its ability to be a perfect white canvas very easily, and the artist should know its behaviour, its character and its future. The same goes for the clay, coal, oil paint, the chemicals, the brushes, the tools, the metal, the glass, the electronics, the stone and many more things that are used in the creation. The materials that need the artist to become once a craftsman. The craftsman can be a thinker, good or bad, but to become an artist, they need to know the material in a way that Jussi Parikka invites as to think about the radio and materiality overall, with the attention of a geologist, dedicated to go all the way to the history of the species and things: «instead of radio, I prefer to think what components and materials enable such technologies; instead of networking, we need to remember the importance of copper or optical fiber for such forms of communication; instead of a blunt discussion of “the digital, ” we need to pick it apart and remember that also mineral durations are essential to it being such a crucial feature that penetrates our academic, social, and economic interests»(J. Parikka, A GEOLOGY OF MEDIA, p.18).

In this sense, the artist is not just a person; it’s a person with the tool and material; it’s a hybrid of early or late technical progress; it’s a chimaera that is too attentive to the connection that holds them together, the connection of creating something from something that was once something else. The artist is the alliance of a human, an instrument and material, that have different continuity as the parts and the whole. And this continuity creates a dramatic disposition between them.


2 Architecture & Cardboard & Cake

​Made-up materiality of dough and concrete. Plus hierarchy of materiality, cheap materials that are made to be destroyed.


Materiality is dramatic; it is the wish of a human-animal for materiality to be equal, to be bending, convenient, to be rare and precious, to be cheap and easy to make. Therefore, the materials have the touch of the wishes and the concepts of the human mind, and they are not the same.

Some materials are made to never change; they bring interesting colour, shape, or the meaning of authenticity that a human should reveal in them. It’s gold, fur, wood, jewels, and pearls, etc. They are unique and hard to make; they evoke magic thinking and attract hunters. They are pure perfection, the idea of themselves, and the materiality of an idea.

Some materials are made to be made into something else; they serve best in architecture, design and confectionery. Concrete might be the best example of it; it bends, it can be formed to any need, it endures the changes and weather, and it is also cheap to produce and very effective. Architecture loves such materials; it loves the unlimited shape creation as much as confectionery arts. Confectionery mastic is the concrete of the cake, and it’s not even particularly edible; the main thing is the creation of shape, volume, the creation of something so artificial and architectural as a thick, big, high, geometrically symmetric cake. The same thought of making anything from anything else is behind both. The ideal material that can be turned into other objects and materials can be prophetically deceiving and playful; it can serve as the material of the imagination and dream with almost no personality and features, except universality and ability to morph.

At the end, there is another type of materiality that is not made to last long. It’s made to be spared, disposed of, cracked, deformed and thrown away with no regret. It’s cardboard that is soaking up water, taking on dust, damage, colour, or smell changes due to air or sun exposure, protecting what is precious and stored inside. Cardboard is so uncomprehensive; it’s hard to place it into one particular place in the human mind, but definitely, it’s one of the most produced, most used and most rejected materials. This material serves as a ‘no’ to the changes of the precious materials that we already discussed above. Cardboard means struggle against time, against the inevitable deaths and end of things; cardboard is a human’s disagreement with materiality. It’s protection, but it’s not gentle; it’s the shell made to be destroyed. At the same time, cardboard has no genuineness, no personality, no origin; it’s a sad, controversial material that is as alienated as it is mundane. Cardboard would be the face of the lowest level in the hierarchy of materials that not only explains the value of things, but also explains the paradoxical value of an artwork, especially if we take into account the material value of the work for the artist, which is the main focus of this text.


I strongly believe that being an artist means being sensitive in a way that connects the disconnected parts. It’s to be sensitive to the world, but also to the craft. It’s to be sensitive to the character of the material, but also to think globally, and to surpass the borders. In this sense, the attention of the artist to the material may not only be instrumental, but also can be reflective of the global processes of materiality, that is, the understanding of the origins, production, capitalistic relationship, labour value and infrastructure. An artist needs to understand infrastructures «as complex sociotechnical systems, with histories of contingency and change (…) connected to the broader structures of privilege, inequality, and justice that shape who has control and whose interests are ignored when it comes to building and repairing infrastructures», as Christopher R. Henke and Benjamin Sims define it in the book “Repairing Infrastructures: The Maintenance of Materiality and Power” (C.Henke, B.Sims, Repairing Infrastructures: The Maintenance of Materiality and Power, p.18).

As everything is connected, the artist, one of the most attentive and sensitive to connections, should be able to acknowledge and respect the tragedy of these connections. And as it’s a tragedy, be able to be brave enough to respect it and to “stay with the trouble”, as Donna J. Haraway states, “of living and dying together” (D. Haraway, Staying with the Trouble: Making Kin in the Chthulucene, p.18). It means not only being responsible for the craft and materials, but also for those who created it with the artist, voluntary or involuntary, at every step of inhuman and speciesist capitalistic production.


3 Experiencing Extraction

The beautiful “prey” of visible and invisible extraction.


Once I have participated in an online laboratory at the ‘Garage Museum of Contemporary Art’, called ‘Setevoe pismo’ (‘Сетевое письмо’, that can be translated as ‘Network-based writing’ or ‘Internet writing’), and one of the meetings of this laboratory was dedicated to eco-poetry and eco-poesis. One of the speakers at the meeting was making a short presentation about “nature” that made me painfully sick and filled me with rage that only environmentalist eco-traumatised people, I believe, can experience. This person talked about “nature” as it was reflected in older mythologies, Chinese natural philosophy, about everything all at once, about vast, unlimited, all-giving, cycle-based, season-changing, old, beautiful, gentle, essential and pretty much understandable (with the words that I have just used) “nature”. And this point of view, which made the extraction to the point of extinction of species possible, made me sick. After the presentation ended their speech, I asked them a few questions.

My first question was, ‘How is it different from the point of view that was clinging to the essential exchange with nature that made the mindless extraction possible’?

My second question was: ‘How is it different from the point of view that Oxana Timofeeva presents in her book “Введение в эротическую философию Жоржа Батая” (Introduction to the Erotic Philosophy of Georges Bataille) in the chapter “Кони в законе” (Horses in the law)? ’ There she is describing the “anthropomorphic machine” that created human logical, righteous and wise self, that is not only ‘human’, but also essential to the ‘nature’ and animal, where ‘human’ is the ideal representer of all good ‘cosmic’ things: «Human beings are both a part of this world and a universal model of it. Other creatures—even the most bizarre among them—approximate this model to varying degrees and possess qualities we readily recognize as human. Some are friendly, others bellicose; some cunning, others guileless; some noble, others not; some courageous, others meek. Animals not only resemble humans but also imitate them in their own way. It is precisely this way around, and not the reverse: a swallow building its nest imitates a human building a house. This is evidenced, according to Aristotle, by the "precision of mind" with which the bird, laying stalks of straw upon the mud, "maintains the very same order" (O. Timofeeva, Introduction to the Erotic Philosophy of Georges Bataille, p.170). This vision of human and non-human animals is simplistic and naive, as it creates false expectations of the ‘animal’ and ‘nature’ to be somehow ‘human’, to respect ‘human’ order of things, that is considered ‘absolute’ or ‘universal’. This approach is not only blinding, but also arrogant; the natural order is expected to be the human order — with the same rules, same morals, same ‘naturality’ of the relationship and things.

My third question was derived from Timothy Morton’s essay (and a book) “Ecology without Nature”: «The paradox of the heap concerns entities that lack sharp boundaries—and many ecological objects, such as a forest or the environment, are essentially of this nature, making the paradox readily applicable to them. If I pluck a leaf from a tree, the forest remains a forest. If I continue removing leaves, then move on to branches, and finally to the trees themselves, then—following this logic—the forest would still remain a forest, even if not a single tree were left in the end. From this, one could easily draw the erroneous conclusion that the forest does not exist» (T. Morton, Ecology without Nature, source: https://www.moscowartmagazine.com/article/252). So, my third question sounds like this: ‘How is this view different from the ‘nature’ that is considered as the whole without questioning it and paying attention to the parts, and how does it take into account that it’s finite? ’

The presenter answered all three questions with one short story that I need to extract from my memory in a loose way. They said something about being in Canada or in the USA in a beautiful forest, so beautiful that it was hard not to pay attention to this beauty. But at the same time, this beautiful place was a logging site; they killed this beauty just in front of their eyes. The presenter concluded that, yes, we can talk about the costs of our life and we can speculate about what we can do, but we simply can not deny or change the fact that we need to kill and destroy others to be alive.

As a female creature, that is as reproductive as nature, and can be a prey of extraction, beautiful and sacrificing, I can only call this vision a vision of ‘rape’. I can not agree in any sense that it is inevitable, that this is the order of things that we need, because it only means to agree to be ‘rapist’, and I can not bring myself to be one. I want to stay with the trouble, and don’t want to be satiated and settled with the explanation of the ‘natural inevitable order’ of things, as there are a lot of awful things that were considered ‘natural’ and ‘order’, and they left me no chance to trust such beliefs anymore.

Therefore, I see the mission of an artist, and my mission, to stay with this trouble, and to reflect it in my art, that I want to be free of cruelty, or at least aim not to be ‘raping’. Therefore, I need and want to find a new gentle way in which my art expression can be shaped by materiality, with attention to the costs of extraction and the cruelty of the things, cruelty that I reject as natural. I want to make art that explores these new ways:

1 I want to be attentive to the costs (what was destroyed, deforested, killed, morphed, diseased, troubled) for the materiality to be

2 I want to understand what place it will take in the world, whose place and for how long

3 I want my art to take as little materiality as possible, to be cyclical and wasteless

4 I want my art to exist, to be performed, to be seen but also to be deformed, extinct and stopped

5 I don’t want to make perfect shapes and objects that should live in the infinity; I accept the end of things and am not to be afraid of losing and never recovering

6 I want to make art for the living and dying, not for the art itself; I don’t want to be pure; I want entanglement in other critters with mud and substances; I want to serve the materiality

7 I want and aim to think against overproduction and overexperimentation

8 I aim to renew in reuse, to no traces, no perfectionism, no trash, to the value of the last pieces and last crumbs

9 I need to be slow, attentive and accept my slowness as a disadvantageable advantage in comparison to the accelerationism of the processes and things

10 I want to bring the materiality the experience of Radical Return


4 Experiencing Radical Return

The means to make an eco-friendly exhibition.

​

The principles of art creation that I have listed might sound idealistic, except that they can be practical. Below is the concept for the perfect exhibition that would use Radical Return as the core mechanic of the show.

But before we get to it, let’s define what it means. Radical Return is opposed to extraction, it is extraction-in-reverse, it’s returning back what was taken, for it to stay untouched, independent from the artwork, like it has never happened. To be able to experience the Radical Return as an artist, one should accept that the artwork won’t last long, will be undone, broken, lost, given back. It means that the approach to an artwork as ‘perfect’, ‘sacred’, ' heritage’, ‘made for centuries’ should be put aside, and moreover, not supported by the Radical Return experience, that is, exposing the life of the artwork as the ordinary object. This exposure represents ‘care’ for materiality, an attempt to fix, or to do the ‘repair’ of (art)production on the individual level.

The artwork can be fragile, unstable, made from non-lasting, disposable materials, may be re- or de- assembled and repurposed into non-art, into functional tools. I propose the concept for a perfect exhibition in the worst times, that bring us closer and closer to the crisis and the End of the World. 

This exhibition may consist of a few types of artworks that could be accepted, considering the principles stated above:


1 — Tribute to Text

Text-making is wonderful. Nowadays it barely needs any material. Digital notes, voice recording — the basic features of modern life — have made text-creating and reading seamless, easy, vitally important. Text-creating doesn’t need any additional materiality, chain of supply, container, transportation or electrical energy. It is fast, sustainable and very-very productive.

With text, any concept and any artwork can be presented, seen/imagined, evaluated and produced very-very fast.


2 — Auseinander Werk

Disassembly Work, an installation-as-toy, constellation of things, nothing cemented or fastened or framed, migration of objects, adhesion to surfaces, floor as paper, floor as canvas for feet.


3 — Funktionale Werk

Functional work, the work that is becoming sustainable or reusable, or just functional during the exhibition. Such work can be water-based, as the water can be distilled, self-purifying and reused immediately for plant watering, for example.  


4 —  Zurückwerk

It is a work that deconstructs itself, returning to its source—to nature or the materiality from which the work and its components were originally extracted. If the work was created from found objects, they must be returned to their original places; this process can take the form of a performance captured on a video.

Documentation thus constitutes the work’s residual trace. What matters is not the materiality itself, but rather its remnants, its sufficiency, or its absence. In the context of an exhibition, Zurückwerk can manifest as a work returned piece by piece, with the dismantling process, involving the replacement of parts with other elements, documentation, or simply emptiness, being recorded.

The ideal conclusion for Zurückwerk is an empty exhibition hall—an exhibition that has gradually dismantled itself, day by day, and returned to its source through the gesture of a Radical Return.

_______________________________________________________________________


Sources

1 — J. Parikka, A GEOLOGY OF MEDIA, p.18

2 — C.Henke, B.Sims, Repairing Infrastructures: The Maintenance of Materiality and Power, p.18

3 — D. Haraway, Staying with the Trouble: Making Kin in the Chthulucene, p.18

4 — O. Timofeeva, Introduction to the Erotic Philosophy of Georges Bataille, p.170

5 — T. Morton, Ecology without Nature, source: https://www.moscowartmagazine.com/article/252


Music

Carl Orff (1895 — 1982) — De temporum fine comoedia


Author

svet
svet
Comment
Share

Building solidarity beyond borders. Everybody can contribute

Syg.ma is a community-run multilingual media platform and translocal archive.
Since 2014, researchers, artists, collectives, and cultural institutions have been publishing their work here

About